Illinois Civil Justice League: Objectivity and Disclosure

December 13, 2004

Objectivity and Disclosure

One thing is certain in the news business: Objectivity is only secure in the mind of the beholder.

The recent debate involving the US Chamber's part ownership of the Madison County Record is an interesting display of professional (and amateur) journalists' views on objectivity. Last week, the Washington Post "broke" a story about the US Chamber's involvement in the new Madison County newspaper. Since then, several colleagues of the Record - from both print and Internet mediums - have expressed opinions on the relationship.

The St. Louis Post-Dispatch weighed in on its new opponent from Edwardsville, saying: "Conflicts of interest - especially a whopper like this one - should always be disclosed." T. Evan Schaeffer, of Notes from the (Legal) Underground, says in a posting yesterday that he hopes the" coverage continues until the Record discloses on its front page that it's nothing but a paid advertisement from tort reformers." Reason Online has posted an opinion on the topic, citing Michael Moore's "Fahrenheit 9/11" as counterpoint in the evolution of liberal interests also mounting untraditional media campaigns.

I enjoy the coverage that the Madison County Record publishes, especially the articles detailing recent lawsuit filings. While disclosure is an important factor in journalistic objectivity, so is balance - and not one of the sources above credited the Record for its outreach to guest editorial writers with differing opinions, including top-of-the-food-chain trial lawyers like Randy Bono and John J. Hopkins. While the paper's editorial and ownership leaning might be evident, the Record has aired opinions from all sides.

I'm pleased to hear a renewed interest from newspapers and lawyers about objectivity and the media. Madison County has its own Michael Moore-like movie crew "covering" the judicial elections and the reform debate - yet there has been no investigation or disclosure as to who is funding the video project? Maybe we should see who is paying the bills for a three person video crew to spend a couple months in Madison County - at least before they hand out their movie to local schools and libraries?


Blogger Evan said...

As for Randy Bono and other guest Op-Ed writers, I'm not sure how far the Madison County Record was "reaching out" to them: Bono told the Post-Dispatch in this article that he felt deceived and quit only after a few week.

Now John Hopkins is providing some commentary, and while I don't agree that this "balances" the newspaper's coverage of Madison County, he's a welcome addition to the paper.

9:26 PM  
Blogger Ed Murnane said...

I became a home delivery subscriber to the Record last night. While I had seen it on-line (and had even been quoted in an article or two), I wasn't totally familiar with the extent of its coverage of the Madison County Court House. Thanks to those who are trying to undermine it, and to local news coverage of it and now an AP story that will attract even wider attention, the Record is likely to see even more circulation gains.

6:24 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home

For more information on Today's legal reform news, check out the ICJL News Update, available everyday by clicking on the gold button above. For recent news headlines from, check out the ICJL Legal Reform News section, available under ICJL Resources.


© 2005 Illinois Civil Justice League